Timothy Foster ConstructionRemodeling Specialists · Est. 1989
Advice · October 6, 2026

Should you refinish or replace those old hardwood floors

Most old hardwood floors can be saved. That is the first thing to know before you get a price on new flooring. Solid hardwood, the kind put down in houses built before the 1970s, was milled thick enough to be sanded several times over its life. If nobody has already sanded it heavily, there is a good chance you have a floor or two of wear left in it.

Here is a simple check. Find a spot where a floor register or vent cover sits, pull it up, and look at the exposed edge of a board. That tells you how thick the wood is above the tongue and groove. If there is a healthy amount of solid wood there, it can likely be refinished. If the board is paper thin or you can see the nail heads have gotten close to the surface from past sandings, you are near the end of what refinishing can do.

Gaps between boards are usually not a reason to replace. Old houses move with the seasons and floors open up a little and close back. Refinishing does not fix a structural problem, it fixes the finish. If the boards themselves are solid and just worn, scratched, or the wrong color for what you want now, refinishing is the right call and it costs a fraction of new flooring.

Replacement becomes the honest answer when the wood itself has failed. Water damage that has cupped or buckled boards for good, rot from a leak that sat too long, boards that are structurally spongy when you walk them, or floors that have already been sanded down past a safe thickness. Sanding a floor that is already thin risks going through the wood entirely, and there is no coming back from that.

Squeaks are their own issue and do not automatically mean replacement either. Often that is a subfloor that has loosened from the joists over the years, and it can be fixed from above or below without touching the finish floor at all. Worth mentioning to whoever looks at your floor, because fixing squeaks and refinishing are two different jobs that sometimes get bundled together when they do not need to be.

One thing that catches people off guard: refinishing does not mean staying with the same color or sheen. You can go lighter, darker, or change from a shiny finish to a satin one. That decision does not change whether you should refinish versus replace, but it is worth deciding before the work starts rather than after, since redoing a finish is its own cost.

If you are comparing a refinish quote against a replacement quote, ask whoever is bidding to explain, in plain terms, why they landed where they did. A contractor who has actually pulled up a register cover and looked at your wood will give you a real answer. One who is guessing off a walkthrough will tell you it needs to go, because replacement is the easier sell and the bigger job.

Give us a call and we can take a look at what you have got before you spend money either direction.

← All advice

Sound like your house? Let's talk.

Request a Quote
Call the OfficeGet a Quote